Iconbar: Anything you can do I can do better

By Chris Williams. Published: 17th Mar 2003, 20:43:50 | Permalink | Printable

iconbar.com shows myriscos.co.uk how polls are really done. Plus we're bored.

Rant | Editorial It's quiet, it's oh so quiet. With no cool RISC OS news emerging, what's an editor to do? Hound companies for news? We've tried. Make up some news? Can't say we're not tempted if only to avoid a non-updated frontpage. However, principles - we've heard of them although we could do with learning some respect. I mean, we could talk about actual real news like the fact that CJE (thanks for the new mouse guys) are selling off their limited stock of the Castle 32bit C/C++ compiler kit at the launch price of a hundred quid. We could talk about Mike Sandells' updated AMPlay, a frontend to the Amplayer MP3 music module. Perhaps review a new version of RiscSearch, the multiple-search-engine-query-launcher app that's been developed by Patrick Mortara for some time now. Maybe we could look at the news of Dr. Andreas Dehmel's Doom It Yourself port which has been made 32 bit compatible besides other changes - you might want to check out Andreas' amusing rant page too, if you're looking to escape from this mindless article.

But oh no, instead we'll focus on the trivial poll battle between iconbar.com and myriscos.co.uk because it seems like something fun to do. We're not getting dragged into this match up, we've booked our tickets in this spectator sport. In the blue corner, we're proud to present to you ladies and gentlemen, the popular mega-forum-site, Paul Vigay obsessed and more-editors-than-you-can-shake-an-apathetic-stick-at, the one and only NoughtPointOne flagship - iconbar.com. And in the red corner tonight, as hosted by Co-Comp and personally recommended by John "Acorn Publisher" Cartmell, the official VA5000 news site and usergroup announcement board rivalling only the AAUG, we give you - myriscos.co.uk. You see, myriscos.co.uk originally posted a poll asking who's going to Wakefield 2003 event. At time of writing, the online voting turnout on myriscos is probably slightly less than the number of UK people supporting an Iraq war right now. Now up steps iconbar.com, probably taking a break from its obvious heavy news reporting and also known for running in depth polls, in our eyes waved a parental finger at myriscos, showing the hapless community website last week how it's really done by asking the same Wakefield attendance question on their frontpage poll. Currently 37% of voters (nice IP logging there) have said they'd definiately be going, which ought to calm the show organisers' and exhibitors' fears.

And so on
Why stop there? We're told that besides other oddities found in the latest March Foundation RiscUser edited by Richard "icons" Hallas this month, the publication advertised to its readers February timed events (so time travel has been ported to RISC OS) and on top of this Acornuser has relaunched this month featuring a crazy new typeface for their article copy. There really is no need for articles like this one, we'd all much rather report on positive news and comments, surely? Right, trust me then when I say we're looking forward to this week's news.

Links

If we left anyone out, drop us an email or preferably, tell us cool things.

Previous: Would you want RISCOS5X-XP?
Next: Three weeks before Omega can ship?

Discussion

Viewing threaded comments | View comments unthreaded, listed by date | Skip to the end

Right, trust me then when I say we're looking forward to this week's news.

Are you trying to tell us something big may happen this week?

Peter

Pete on 18/3/03 10:08AM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Surely when you're talking about the number of people attending, you want the absolute values, not just a percentage. I doubt 37% of the RISC OS user group will be going. (More likely 95%, considering how many are around these days ;-)

nunfetishist on 18/3/03 10:21AM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Yes, I only realised the poll would be of limited use after I'd set the damn thing up. Still, it does seems as though more people have voted than on myriscos.

The Doctor on 18/3/03 10:50AM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Pete: Yeah man, theres a war on man, a war. Ain't that a b***h.

-- Snig Undoubtley doubtfull.

Snig on 18/3/03 10:52AM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Bia gum Chris - you really do need to get out more often!

Nodoid on 18/3/03 11:32AM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Wonderful. A voting system on iconbar that locks a lot of people out of voting as soon as 1 person votes through an 'ISP forced-you-will-use-this' proxy server. Looks like all the people using freeserve, and btopenworld can only have an astounding collecive '1' vote.

Entirely accurate system, oh yes.

piemmm on 18/3/03 11:33AM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Web polls are completely pointless and inaccurate for this reason - there's no good way of stopping people voting more than once. (cookies are easy to get around, IP locking for the reason above. And you forgot NTL, too ;-)

nunfetishist on 18/3/03 12:31PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

You could check the X-Forwarded-For: header from the proxy (if it sends it),.. but I've got a 'modified' proxy that deliberately puts randomised ones of those out.

You could do a heuristic time/ip based check to make sure a user doesnt vote lots within X days, but that's easily got round (but more time consuming) with crontabs and a couple of boxes on the net.

You could force each user to login to vote, which would be better, although you'd get some crazy a$$ed s0d whinging about the Data Protection Act, and privacy concerns.

You could use cookies to help stop double-voting, but hell, I could use wget and ignore cookies totally.

You could get the user to type in a 'picture generated text' thing, each time they vote (like SMS portals used to have), but you'd end up with no votes, as nobody would be bothered enough to go to that much effort even to use it properly.

You could do similar, but also have a 'answer this riddle/very simple question' thing, make it funny, and people might use it (defeating the automatic bot-type stuff), but that doesnt help for double-voters...

Or you could munge all of the above together in some fashion, and have something that was still inaccurate :-)

-- Ian Hawkins

piemmm on 18/3/03 1:09PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

> You could force each user to login to vote, which would be better, although you'd get some crazy a$$ed s0d whinging about the Data Protection Act, and privacy concerns.

That's the best way to go, AFAIC. If you don't want to give your details, don't vote ;-)

moss on 18/3/03 1:18PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Exactly what Myriscos do. And no-one

[edited mangled comment - Chris, 14:31 18/3/2003]

The Doctor on 18/3/03 2:27PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Sigh! I really must ask Andrew to fix this. Sorry about that.

The Doctor on 18/3/03 2:28PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Actually it does allow more than one vote per IP, but still, it's just a web-based poll, doesn't have to be 100% accurate.

And incidentally I believe Freeserve and NTL both have a number of different web proxies, and I didn't think BT O actually had one at all?

tfountain on 18/3/03 3:58PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

IIRC, BTOW stick you through a transparent proxy, and there's always been the venerable cache.bt.net

Yes, freeserve, and NTL do have multiple proxies, but there's only so many of those about. I'd like to think that there's still more RISC OS users than proxies :-)

Your voting booth is a bit limiting at the moment though - it was 45/45 zap/stronged for *ages* ;-)

So, when put more news on tib frontpage?

-- Ian Hawkins

piemmm on 18/3/03 4:09PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

I'm overdosing on smileys!

piemmm on 18/3/03 4:10PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

> So, when put more news on tib frontpage? :-)

When we get a scoop :-p

moss on 18/3/03 4:45PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

When I write a stylesheet for drobe's RSS feed

Hertzsprung on 18/3/03 6:42PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Awwww, nasty smiley images.

nunfetishist on 18/3/03 6:56PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

> So, when put more news on tib frontpage?

When there is something worth reporting on

andypoole on 18/3/03 6:57PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

This is an amazing insight into the editorial thinking of TIB: "When there is something worth reporting on". I could bitch about how TIB consider things like Artworks 2, Front Ender, Omega in Germany and more to be non-news (as well as providing zero editorial) but instead I'll just sit here in disappointment and dissaproval.

Chris, drobe.co.uk

diomus on 18/3/03 7:01PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

But you're not, *are you* drobe >:-|

Hertzsprung on 18/3/03 7:24PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

> This is an amazing insight into the editorial thinking of TIB

No, it's an amazing insight into what you think of Andy Poole. Not all the editors. Far, far too much generalisation there.

moss on 18/3/03 7:24PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

So who are the editors of TIB?

Hertzsprung on 18/3/03 7:25PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

[link]

andypoole on 18/3/03 7:26PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Shirley it should be :-

...Anything you can do Iconbar better...

:-)

))

-- Nick

nickydeb on 18/3/03 9:36PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

That's pretty sweet. You're hired. Or something.

Chris, drobe.co.uk

diomus on 18/3/03 10:41PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Calm down, guys. Can't you all join forces? Gawd knows someone in the community has to!

ribbit on 27/3/03 5:59PM
[ Reply | Permalink | Report ]

Please login before posting a comment. Use the form on the right to do so or create a free account.

Search the archives

Today's featured article

Adventures with a Lego-cased A7K web server
Having previously built desktop and laptop cases of out Lego bricks, model building Peter Howkins has turned his attentions towards crafting a slim box to slid his A7000 into a rack, alongside other rackmount servers. Having pieced together the housing, Peter puts a legacy RISC OS machine through its paces as an internet-facing server.

11 comments, latest by jess on 3/12/08 2:07PM. Published: 21 Nov 2008

Random article

Select for Iyonix needs cooperation
Support from manufacturers, ie: Castle

25 comments, latest by TonyStill on 12/3/04 11:03PM. Published: 5 Mar 2004

Useful links

News and media:
Iconbar • MyRISCOS • ArcSite • RISCOScode • ANS • C.S.A.Announce • Archive • Qercus • RiscWorld • Drag'n'Drop • GAG-News

Top developers:
RISCOS Ltd • RISC OS Open • MW Software • R-Comp • Advantage Six • VirtualAcorn

Dealers:
CJE Micros • APDL • Castle • a4 • X-Ample • Liquid Silicon • Webmonster

Usergroups:
WROCC • RONE • NKACC • IRUG • SASAUG • ROUGOL • RONWUG • MUG • WAUG • GAG • RISCOS.be

Useful:
RISCOS.org.uk • RISCOS.org • RISCOS.info • Filebase • Chris Why's Acorn/RISC OS collection • NetSurf

Non-RISC OS:
The Register • The Inquirer • Apple Insider • BBC News • Sky News • Google News • xkcd • diodesign

© 1999-2009 The Drobe Team. Some rights reserved, click here for more information
Powered by MiniDrobeCMS, based on J4U | Statistics
"...a somewhat shallow article intended only to generate some journalistic controversy"
Page generated in 0.0629 seconds.